MDES Engineering Logo
English
TECHNICAL SELECTION GUIDE

Ball, Butterfly, Gate, Globe and Check Valve Differences

Valve type is selected from duty, pressure loss, shut-off requirement, flow direction, operating frequency and fluid properties—not pipe size alone.

Direct answer

Valve type is selected from duty, pressure loss, shut-off requirement, flow direction, operating frequency and fluid properties—not pipe size alone.

Technical review: MDES Engineering Technical TeamUpdated: 2026-10-25
Ball, Butterfly, Gate, Globe and Check Valve Differences

Ball and butterfly valves

Full-port ball valves provide low pressure loss and tight quarter-turn isolation. Butterfly valves are compact and economical at medium and large diameters; disc, seat and actuator torque must be checked together.

Gate and globe valves

Gate valves are intended for fully open or fully closed isolation. Globe valves are better suited to throttling and control, but their flow path creates a higher pressure drop.

Check valves

Check valves automatically prevent reverse flow. Swing, wafer, disc or spring-loaded designs are selected by velocity, orientation, closing dynamics and water-hammer risk.

Final verification

Confirm DN/NPS, PN/class, body, trim and seat materials, end connection, temperature and leakage requirement on one technical datasheet.

Typical valve duties

TypePrimary dutyKey characteristic
BallQuick isolationLow loss, tight shut-off
ButterflyLarge-diameter isolation/controlCompact and light
GateOpen/closed isolationLow loss when fully open
GlobeThrottling/controlGood modulation
CheckPrevent reverse flowAutomatic operation

Key points

  • Define isolation or control duty.
  • State fluid, pressure and temperature.
  • Check pressure loss and surge.
  • Verify seat and material compatibility.

Frequently asked technical questions

Should a gate valve regulate flow?

Normally no; it is primarily for fully open or fully closed isolation.

Is every butterfly valve suitable for every fluid?

No. Disc, seat and body materials must match fluid, pressure and temperature.

Why does a globe valve have higher loss?

The fluid changes direction through the body and passes the control trim.

What is critical for check-valve selection?

Minimum flow, orientation, closing speed and surge risk.

Technical references

  • Emerson Control Valve Handbook
  • Manufacturer pressure-temperature and material data
  • Project piping and process criteria